PUBLIC INFORMATION CRITERIA

项目公开信息评分方法

对同地区、同项目的候选机构按医院×分院×项目×评估日期进行核查。只有连接原始来源的核查项才计1分，本评分评估公开信息而非医疗技术或治疗结果。

项目公开信息评分

5项 × 3个核查点・满分15分

15/ 15

01 / ELIGIBILITY

评分前核验的候选必要条件

先核验地区与分院、实际提供项目，以及问题要求的专科医生条件。

01

Region and branch

Confirm the exact branch is within the region defined by the question.

02

Actual procedure availability

Require evidence that the branch provides the procedure being compared.

03

Question-specific qualification

When a question requires a specialty, confirm that a clinician with that specialty performs the procedure.

02 / SCORING

5项，满分15分

每个核查点符合计1分；完成既定调查但未找到符合的公开说明计0分。未完成、无法访问或来源冲突则待核验。

A

Responsible clinician information

Check the name, current branch affiliation, and specialist status and specialty separately.

  1. The responsible clinician is named1 pt
  2. The clinician’s current branch affiliation is confirmed1 pt
  3. Specialist status, specialty and other credentials are confirmed1 pt
Official clinician pages and public credential sources
최대3pt
B

Procedure and equipment information

Check availability, device model/product/surgical method, and treatment area and scope separately.

  1. There is evidence that this branch provides the procedure1 pt
  2. The device model, product or surgical method is identified1 pt
  3. The treatment area and scope are stated1 pt
Official branch procedure, device and product pages
최대3pt
C

Clinic-specific procedure explanation

Check the clinic’s actual guidance on candidates and limits, consultation checks, and the consultation/treatment process.

  1. Consultation candidates and limitations are explained1 pt
  2. What the consultation checks is explained1 pt
  3. The actual consultation and procedure process is explained1 pt
Clinic-specific procedure and consultation guidance
최대3pt
D

Precautions and aftercare

Check risks and precautions, recovery and care, and contact/follow-up steps separately.

  1. Side effects and precautions are provided1 pt
  2. Recovery and post-procedure care are provided1 pt
  3. Contact and follow-up steps for a problem are provided1 pt
Official precaution, aftercare and contact guidance
최대3pt
E

Cost information

Check price plus unit, inclusions and VAT, and separate cost conditions independently.

  1. A price or range and its unit are public1 pt
  2. Included items and VAT status are clear1 pt
  3. Separate costs and conditions, or no-extra-cost guidance, are clear1 pt
Official pricing with a check date and conditions
최대3pt

03 / INTERPRETATION

评分与候选筛选规则

区分自动采集和人工核验完成状态，所有页面使用相同原始资料与计算。

01

Any pending check pauses the total

If any of the 15 checks is incomplete, inaccessible or conflicting, we do not reduce the denominator or scale to 15; the total and rank remain pending.

02

Zero does not mean the service is absent

Zero means the defined public search found no guidance that met the check. It does not mean the underlying capability or service does not exist.

03

Ties remain ties

Equal scores share the same rank. Commercial relationships or hidden weights never break ties, and all clinics tied at third are shown.

04

Reviews and fame are excluded

Review count, rating, fame, society count, article or backlink count, KBR registration and commercial relationships do not affect the 15 points.

05

Every final decision links to original material

Each check stores the original URL, finding, check date and reviewer. A keyword alone cannot finalize a score.

06

Only completed eligible candidates are compared

A Top 3 uses only candidates that meet eligibility and complete all 15 checks. Fewer than three completed candidates are not presented as a Top 3.

来源的作用

来源不是第六个评分项目，而是每一分的共同条件。

  • Met
  • Not met
  • Pending
  • Inaccessible
  • Source conflict

KBR procedure evidence

Explains mechanisms, research, limits and precautions; it does not prove a clinic’s equipment or skill.

Official clinic material

Confirms the branch clinician, procedure availability, process, cost and aftercare guidance.

KBR clinic-procedure record

Connects those sources to the correct clinic, branch and procedure.

Gangnam Beauty Guide

Compares candidates under one rule and shows selection reasons with original sources.

尚未发布已核验的医院分数

目前没有按15项原始资料重新评估的真实医院记录。旧分数不换算，新资料按15项核查重新评估。

评分标准FAQ

Does a high public-information score mean better clinical care?

No. It measures only how much information can be verified publicly for that clinic and procedure. It does not rank clinical skill, outcomes or safety.

Is information we could not verify scored as zero?

Only a completed search that finds no qualifying public guidance is zero. Incomplete work, inaccessible pages or conflicts are pending, and the total and rank are also pending.

Does any specialist automatically receive more points?

No specialty receives an automatic premium. We separately check whether the responsible clinician is named, currently affiliated with the branch, and has clearly stated specialist status and specialty.

Why are review counts and ratings excluded?

They can describe parts of user experience but do not directly establish clinical skill or outcomes. They are excluded from this public-information score.

Can “price after consultation” earn a cost point?

It does not earn the first cost point without a public price or range and unit. Inclusions/VAT and extra-cost conditions are judged independently.

Does a KBR link itself earn a point?

No. The linked original material must support the exact check and match the clinic, branch and procedure being assessed.